I will first state my main (and only) complaint about this episode, the first scene. It feels so slapped in and we don't need it. And Connie and Whit are very unconvincing, although Wooton is pretty convincing. The rest of the episode is much better and this scene is just a disappointment. I like the whole postcard and youtube video style to bring back Wooton's memory. I am glad they forgoed using Eugene in favor of Jason, as Jason works really well in this episode. I am a little suspicious of Pablo right now.
I give Find a Penny, Part I a resounding 4.5 out of 5 and I will review Part II soon!